nighty-nine nights good or bad? What do you think?

[Shadarlog]

I decided to reserve my thoughts on this game to see what the true hack and slash gamers out there think. Me I like rpgs and I find N3 to lack depth in both it's cut scenes and gameplay, but I want to know what you guys out there feel. I am considering keeping the game because a girl I know absolutely loves it, but is a cute girl's smile worth keeping a game I do not find that inovative or engrossing. When there are better titles comeing out soon I could trade it in for such as elemental arms and saints row.

[reploidx]

well, i consider to be a true hack and slash guy. I play fighters or pallys in every game or play (or a fighting paladin). I've had people yell at me for making an undefeatable fighter in Dungeons and Dragons. So when i saw N3, i said to my self "i played this game, its called dynasty warriors" and its a pretty looking dynasty warriors with new looking chinese people to play as and beat up. Honestly, if this girl likes this game, go buy dynasty warriors empires, its for the 360 (originally ps2) and its basically the same thing, only with chinese guys and you can make your own empirer. But other than that, go buy oblivion, or some other rpg (it seems 360 is lacking, i'm not sure though) but if you like the game, then keep it (or buy it if you didn't) but other than that, its the same thing that koei has been making forever.